Ben Adler on February 3, 2012 - 4:06pm ET
Newt Gingrich has taken phony cultural populism to its logical
extreme. Gingrich abandons his supposed free market and small
government principles when it comes to federally subsidizing
over-consumption of housing. That's both a biographical fact, in light
of his work for Freddie Mac, and a policy position.
To make the point that anyone who disagrees with him on housing policy
is just an elite liberal snob, instead of engaging them on substantive
economic policy grounds, Gingrich has taken to mocking people who
don't own a detached single-family home in the suburbs and drive
everywhere.
At the National Association of Home Builders, "Rally for
Homeownership" in South Carolina, Gingrich said, "Those who, you know,
live in high-rise apartment buildings writing for fancy newspapers in
the middle of town after they ride the metro, who don't understand
that for most Americans the ability to buy a home, to have their own
property, to have a sense of belonging is one of the greatest
achievements of their life, and it makes them feel like they are good
solid citizens." As Matthew Yglesias wrote in Slate, "it's telling how
swiftly any kind of commitment to free market economics melts away in
the face of the identity politics concerns of prosperous older white
suburbanites."
On Friday he reiterated his hatred of people who live a more
environmentally efficient lifestyle. Speaking in Las Vegas ahead of
the Nevada caucus, a contest he is sure to lose, Gingrich attacked
"elites" in Manhattan who live in high rises and "ride the subway."
This is the perfect distillation of Gingrichism on many levels. First
it shows the stupidity and ignorance of a man Republicans praise for
his intelligence and knowledge. Riding the subway is much cheaper than
owning, maintaining and driving a car. The truly rich in New York take
cabs, car services or drive more often than the poor. Not everyone in
Manhattan, or in a high-rise, is an elite: Gingrich has apparently
never ventured north of 96th Street and seen who lives in the
high-rise projects in Harlem.
Gingrich still seems to live in the last decade that he was relevant:
the 1990s. Back then his despised media elites mostly lived in
Manhattan. (Of the ones who live in the city. Plenty of them live in
the suburbs and it's unclear whether Gingrich thinks that makes them
real Americans.)
Now, journalists and other underpaid urban professionals increasingly
live in Brooklyn and Queens, but Gingrich's demagoguery is behind the
times. It's also outdated because the reason writers have been largely
pushed out of Manhattan is the influx of ever-wealthier bankers, the
sort of people Gingrich says we should worship as job creators. It's
time for Gingrich to start loving Manhattan instead of hating it. Then
again, some of the financiers work for private equity firms, and since
Gingrich is running against a private equity executive, he has decided
that those capitalists are inherently different and worse than all
others.
Since Gingrich is having a little trouble keeping his culture war
motifs straight, I decided to help him. Out with the Chardonnay,
Manhattan, New York Times and brie. In with the boroughs, pilsner,
websites and free-range chickens. Here are some future depictions of
out of touch urban elites, reflecting current demographic trends, that
Gingrich should use:
"Elites who walk on sidewalks and wear used clothing"
"Elites who sit on brownstone stoops and shop at organic food co-ops"
"bagel-eating elites who read Gawker"
"Elites who eat pizza by the slice and ride bicycles"
"Elites who call stores 'bodegas'"
"Elites who go to that topless beach next to Riis Park"
"Elites who make their own seltzer at home with one of those
soda machines"
"Micro-brew drinking elites who live in Bushwick"
"Elites who have plaid shirts and moustaches, but in an ironic way"
"Elites who drink cheap domestic beer, but not because they're
too American to realize it tastes bad"
If Gingrich deploys these updated demagogic smears, he will be sure to
resonate with younger voters. He can thank me when he wins in
November.
More:
http://www.thenation.com/blog/166069/newt-gingrichs-new-enemies-subway-riders
--
Together, we can change the world, one mind at a time.
Have a great day,
Tommy
--
Together, we can change the world, one mind at a time.
Have a great day,
Tommy
--
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum
* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls.
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
No comments:
Post a Comment